Why Matthew Short Does Not Fit In Chennai Super Kings' IPL 2027 Plans

Matthew Short in CSK jersey. Image Credits: AFPMatthew Short has slowly established himself as one of the best all-rounders in T20s. This year, he has been in sensational form and contributed immensely with both bat and ball.For the same reason, Short has also found a spot in Australia’s white-ball squads amid high competition at the top. Even Chennai Super Kings (CSK) bought him out of nowhere for IPL 2026.Matthew Short’s impressive returns in 2026Matthew Short has been in fine form this yearMatthew Short has been among the most consistent all-round performers in T20 cricket this year. In 28 innings in 2026, he has amassed 858 runs at an average of 37.30 and a strike rate of 139.28, including three fifties and a century.With the ball, the Australian all-rounder has been equally effective, claiming 22 wickets at an average of 20.90 and an economy rate of 8.41 in 24 outings, with a best of four wickets in an innings.Short has represented Australia and four different T20 franchises in 2026, making an impact in almost every competition. His standout campaign came in Major League Cricket (MLC), where he starred for the San Francisco Unicorns.He piled up 513 runs at a remarkable average of 64.12 and a strike rate of 146.15 in 12 innings, including a fifty and a century. Short also picked up 17 wickets at an outstanding average of 13.11, producing one of the finest all-round seasons in the tournament's history.He has carried that form into The Hundred 2026 with Welsh Fire. In his first four outings, Short has scored 120 runs at an average of 41.33 and a strike rate of 136.26 while also taking three wickets, once again underlining his ability to adapt seamlessly to different conditions and competitions.How CSK failed to utilise Matthew Short in IPL 2026Matthew Short batted out of position for CSKChennai Super Kings entered the IPL 2026 auction in search of an off-spin all-rounder to fill the void left by Ravichandran Ashwin's retirement. With only a mini auction to work with, the options were limited, and CSK eventually settled on Matthew Short.However, they never showed complete faith in the Australian all-rounder, handing him only three appearances throughout the season. Short managed just 60 runs at a strike rate of 117.64 in those games, while conceding 12.31 runs per over without taking a wicket.Also Read: First Reaction From CSK Camp Emerges After Stephen Fleming’s ExitThe lack of opportunities was one issue, but the role wasn't ideal either. Short batted outside the top three in two of his three innings, despite being a player whose game is built around batting at the top of the order.The numbers highlight the difference. Across 25 innings in the top three this year, Short has scored 795 runs at an average of 39.75 and a strike rate of 142.98, including three fifties and a century. On the contrary, outside the top three, he has managed only 63 runs in three innings at a modest strike rate of 105. In fact, he has rarely succeeded as a middle-order batter throughout his career, which is one reason he has struggled to cement a regular place in Australia's T20I side.CSK's thinking was understandable. They viewed Short as a batter capable of taking on pace. This skill could complement a middle order featuring Dewald Brevis, Shivam Dube, Sarfaraz Khan and Kartik Sharma, all of whom are accomplished against spin but can be vulnerable to hard lengths and short-pitched pace.The plan was for Short to counter fast bowlers while providing useful off-spin against favourable matchups. The problem is that his batting profile doesn't suit that role. While he excels against pace, he has his own shortcomings against spin. This year, he has struck at only 124 against slow bowlers and requires 7.32 balls per boundary.Those numbers make it difficult for him to thrive as a middle-order batter. Oppositions can restrict him with accurate stump-line spin and quicker bowling through the air, limiting his ability to impose himself during the middle overs with a spread field.How Matthew Short doesn’t fit in the CSK setupMatthew Short has issues with spinIf Chennai Super Kings are to get the best out of Matthew Short, they need to play him in the top three. Unfortunately, that is not possible at the moment. Following Sanju Samson's arrival, CSK already have a well-stocked top order.Samson, Ruturaj Gaikwad and Ayush Mhatre appear to be the first-choice top three, while Sarfaraz Khan and Urvil Patel are also capable options. More importantly, all of them are better players of spin than Short, leaving little room for the Australian at the top.That, in turn, exposes the bigger issue. Short is not naturally suited to a middle-order role, yet there is no opening in the top order for him. Carrying an overseas player who does not fit the role makes little sense, especially when his off-spin alone is unlikely to justify selection. While his bowling has improved noticeably in recent times, the IPL's increasingly batting-friendly surfaces offer limited assistance to spin, reducing his overall value.In a full-strength XI, CSK's four overseas spots are likely to be occupied by Dewald Brevis, Jamie Overton, Noor Ahmad and Nathan Ellis. That leaves no realistic pathway for Short unless injuries force a reshuffle. If CSK still want a spin-bowling all-rounder, they would be better served investing in an Indian option who can also bat in the middle order.Hence, CSK should release Matthew Short ahead of IPL 2027. They would be better off using that overseas spot on a player who naturally fits the middle order, while targeting an Indian off-spin all-rounder to cover the skill set they actually need.Also Read: How Mohammad Amir's British Citizenship Could Bring An End To His PSL Career