R Ashwin Says He Warned Gautam Gambhir [Source: AFP]
India's dominance in home Test cricket came to an abrupt end during New Zealand's tour in 2024, when the visitors secured a historic 3-0 series victory.
The defeat exposed India's struggles against quality spin bowling and raised questions about the conditions prepared for the matches.
Nearly two years later, former India spinner R Ashwin has revisited that difficult period, revealing that he had raised concerns about the team's approach even before the series began.
R Ashwin Says He Warned Gautam Gambhir About Turning Pitches Against New Zealand
India had not lost a home Test series since England's 2012 tour before New Zealand arrived in October 2024. The hosts had built an impressive record under Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma, making Indian conditions particularly difficult for visiting teams.
However, New Zealand brought that remarkable run to an end with a 3-0 whitewash. Looking back at the series on Aakash Chopra's podcast Baith and Bol, Ashwin identified it as one of his most disappointing experiences in Indian cricket.
"For me, the New Zealand series (at home) was the most disappointing. I had told coach Gautam Gambhir and everyone that we don't need to play on such turning wickets.
"Because on such turning wickets, spinners from both sides will come face-to-face and then there is not much time for skill and they can't dismiss the batsmen," Ashwin said.
Ashwin's argument was that extreme turn could reduce the importance of a spinner's skill, allowing visiting teams with quality slow bowlers to exploit the same conditions as India's own attack.
India's History With Turning Pitches As South Africa Also Exploit Home Conditions
The 2024 series against New Zealand was not the first time India struggled after preparing spin-friendly conditions at home. Visiting teams have previously found ways to use such surfaces to their advantage.
England's 2012-13 tour remains a notable example. Monty Panesar and Graeme Swann troubled the Indian batting line-up with their spin bowling, helping England secure a memorable 2-1 series victory.
Australia produced another warning in Pune during the opening Test of their 2017 tour. Nathan Lyon picked up eight wickets in the first innings, helping the visitors defeat India on a surface that offered considerable assistance to spin. India recovered from that setback, won the remaining three Tests and claimed the series 2-1.
However, concerns about India's approach to home pitches resurfaced after another disappointing result against South Africa in 2025. The Proteas won the two-match Test series 2-0, with spin-friendly conditions again becoming a major talking point.















