Tilak Varma's Strike Rate Debate: Are Numbers Strong Enough To Counter The Narrative?

Tilak Varma has been criticised for his strike rate [Source: AP]

Experienced Indian batter Tilak Varma has been facing the heat for quite a while now. Despite oozing his class with the bat, Tilak has frequently been questioned for his batting approach, with critics launching scathing attacks on the seasoned campaigner. 

The Indian cricket team, led by Shreyas Iyer, had a torrid time in the UK, failing to win a single T20I match against Ireland and England. While most of his teammates couldn't live up to the expectations, it was Tilak Varma who received massive backlash, with fans and critics accusing him of playing with a subpar strike rate. 

We can sense a narrative being built around Tilak Varma's strike rate, as the southpaw continues to grab the negative attention. But do the numbers actually justify the narrative that he has slowed down as a T20I batter? 

The narrative: How did Tilak Varma's strike rate become a national issue?

Tilak Varma had an outstanding start to his T20I career, as he smacked four scintillating fifty-plus scores in his first 19 outings. The left-handed batter registered a remarkable strike rate of 161.26 while also maintaining an average of 51.33 in his first two years as a T20I cricketer. 

However, Tilak Varma's strike rate significantly declined in 2025, as he struck at 129.16 across 18 T20I innings in 2025. 

An unsuccessful T20 World Cup 2026 campaign, where Tilak could amass only 207 runs across nine innings, added fuel to the fire, while the Ireland T20Is, which he finished with a strike rate of 110.45, made critics frame the negative narrative around his batting approach. 

Thus, despite having an incredible start to his T20I career in 2023, Tilak grabbed the attention for the wrong reasons three years later, following India's shambolic losses in Ireland. 

Dissecting the drop in Tilak Varma's strike rate in 2025

(Indian batters in T20Is in 2025)

It's worth noting that although Tilak managed only 207 runs in the T20 World Cup 2026, his strike rate in the tournament read 154.48. So, the overall drop in his strike rate was primarily related to the Asia Cup as well as the T20I series against England, Australia and South Africa in 2025. 

However, while Tilak received a lot of flak for his scoring rate, he statistically maintained a higher strike rate than designated swashbucklers like Sanju Samson and Suryakumar Yadav. 

Shubman Gill and Hardik Pandya were faster than Tilak, but the latter was the most consistent among all the Indian batters, averaging 47.25 in T20Is in 2025. Only Abhishek Sharma, India's most successful T20I batter in 2025, recorded more runs than Tilak that year. 

As the Asia Cup was played on the sluggish pitches of the Dubai International Cricket Stadium, Tilak had to bat with a cautious approach for the sake of India's success in the tournament. 

With Abhishek Sharma providing the Indian team with brisk starts, Tilak emerged as the backbone of the batting unit, producing impactful knocks, including a match-winning fifty in the all-important final. 

His valiant half-century showcased Tilak's ability to excel in high-pressure situations, an attribute that sets him apart from typical modern-day hitters. 

Tilak undoubtedly endured a rough patch on the Australia tour but took little time to bounce back in the home series against South Africa, registering an average of 62.33. 

Also Read: Tilak Varma Becomes 1st Recipient Of BCCI's Newly Introduced Award

Tilak Varma's strike rate in 2026 shows an upward trend

While the narrative has mostly been about how Tilak Varma's strike rate hasn't met the modern-day standards of late, the southpaw has actually improved his numbers in T20Is this year. 

(Tilak Varma's strike rate has increased in 2026)

As evidenced by the data presented in the above table, Tilak Varma's strike rate has increased from 129.16 in 2025 to 148.08 in 2026. Thus, the numbers show a significant 14.64 per cent increase, showcasing that Tilak has indeed improved his scoring rate this year. 

The fact that Tilak's average has taken a hit of almost 12 points highlights that the batter has sacrificed his consistency to empower the team with a more aggressive batting option in the middle-order. With Shreyas Iyer returning to the T20I setup, Tilak has shifted his focus from being a reliable anchor to a fierce scorer, exhibiting remarkable flexibility and adaptability. 

Tilak has excelled as a lower middle-order batter, scoring 334 runs in 13 innings at numbers 5 and 6 at a superb strike rate of 155.34 in 2026. He has registered a strike rate of more than 150 in three out of four series he has played this year. 

If we compare Tilak with his contemporaries from other countries, the Indian batter is one of the five players who have scored more than 200 runs at these positions at a strike rate higher than 150. 

Numbers weaken the narrative by showing Tilak's versatility

The Asia Cup 2025, where Tilak Varma's strike rate read 131.48, highlighted his ability to deliver match-winning performances under pressure. He played a game-changing knock of 69 runs when Pakistan had pushed India down on the mat with three wickets for 20 runs. 

Furthermore, as the Indian team management tried Vaibhav Sooryavanshi at the top order and brought Ishan Kishan back at number three, Tilak Varma was allotted numbers five and six, where a batter is required to play with an aggressive intent from the get-go. 

Despite being frequently exposed to vastly contrasting match situations, Tilak registered a net increase in his strike rate, acing a more difficult role with ease and elegance. For example, when the Indian team needed him to accelerate, Tilak hammered 25-ball 53 in the Southampton T20I before following it up with another fiery 29-ball 60* in the Zimbabwe series. 

In his own admission, Tilak stated that being the vice-captain of the team, he needs to bat with more responsibility and set an example for his teammates by adapting to different match situations. 

Thus, the narrative that Tilak deserves to be criticised for his strike rate is dismissed, as cricket is a game of situations and demands a calculated approach rather than raw aggression. 

Also Read: Delhi Capitals Join Hardik Pandya Trade Race To Offer 2 Big Indian Stars